A Closer Look at ETF Liquidity

Published by Harvest ETFs

The rise of ETFs over the past 15 years has led to questions about how easy they might be to buy and sell, especially if trading volume is low or during a market downturn.

The question about how easy an ETF is to trade is a question about its liquidity. This is the degree to which an ETF can be quickly bought or sold without affecting its market price.  The short answer is that in most cases this should not be a concern to investors.

What is an ETF

An ETF is a Fund structure, similar to a mutual fund, in that they both offer investors a proportionate share in a basket of securities. They are pooled investment vehicles that offer diversified exposure to a particular area of the market. They can invest in stocks, bonds or a blend of assets. Each investor buys units of the ETF, which represent an amount of interest in the pooled assets.

The first ETF was introduced as an investment strategy that tracks a particular Index, commonly referred to as an index ETF or passive strategy. Over the past decade, new ETFs have entered the market, covering a wide range of risk appetites and investment goals, including a plethora of active strategies. Investors now have access to a broad array of ETF’s, covering every corner of the market, asset classes (equity, bonds, currency, commodities, sectors and derivatives), available in passive or a variation of actively managed.

Like a traditional mutual fund, an ETF tracks the combined performances of the investments that are held within it. Like a mutual fund, an ETF can hold stocks or bonds. A key difference is the ETF can be traded at a known market price during the time the market is open, compared to a mutual fund that prices at the end of the day only. There may also be some cost advantages associated with the ETF because of the operation structure.

A common misconception about ETF liquidity

Many investors think that if an ETF doesn’t trade actively the fund is illiquid and should be avoided. That question might make sense from the perspective of a single stock. The gap between its bid and ask price can be wide if a stock does not frequently trade. But with ETFs, you have two levels of liquidity – that of the ETF and that of the underlying stocks. Both are facilitated by the involvement of an intermediary called a market maker.

Role of the Market Maker

A designated market maker, sometimes called a designated broker (DB), is a dealer or investment firm that plays an essential role in ensuring ETF liquidity. Their responsibility is to maintain an inventory of units of the ETF and ensure investors can buy and sell when they choose to do so. The market maker ensures there is always a buyer or seller for the investor at an accurate price. The ETF will track during the day the underlying holdings (ie. the stocks held in the Fund).

Market makers create liquidity by always being ready to buy or sell shares for investors.

How a Market Maker Works

Market makers create ETF units by delivering the basket of stocks held by the ETF to the ETF provider in exchange for a block of units of the ETF with the same market value. These newly created ETF units can be sold on the stock exchange to investors.  When the market maker runs out of ETF units because investors have purchased them all, they repeat the process. This process works in reverse with redemptions. Here, the market maker exchanges ETF units with the ETF provider, for an equivalent basket of stocks that make up the ETF.

Bid and Ask Prices 

The market maker also tries to keep the bid and ask price of the ETF within a narrow band, so that it closely approximates the ETF’s net asset value (NAV) per unit throughout the trading day. They do so by providing units of ETFs on the stock exchange at asking prices of sellers and then posting bid prices, which are the prices at which they will purchase units for investors wishing to sell. The bids and ask prices are calculated based upon the underlying asset values, and the costs and fees associated with buying or selling the underlying securities inside the ETF.

Liquidity of underlying stocks

In general, the only factor which could affect the liquidity of an ETF is the liquidity of its underlying portfolio of securities. The same is true for a mutual Fund. If someone sells a mutual fund, the Portfolio Manager must sell the underlying securities within it for the redemptions. If the ETF or mutual fund invests in stocks that are thinly traded, then the portfolio manager or the market maker may have difficulty buying or selling them. This could affect the market maker’s ability to redeem units of the ETF.

When you sell the ETF, you are essentially selling the underlying stocks in their proportion in the ETF and that is an important distinction, facilitated by a market maker. A thinly traded ETF can be highly liquid: If the underlying stocks are easy to buy or sell, so is the ETF.

Given that Harvest ETFs invest primarily in liquid large and mid-cap securities, we do not anticipate any issues within our fund complex. Therefore, this point is not so relevant to Harvest.

As with all investments, ETFs are not a one-size fits all decision. It pays to take a close look at the component stocks of ETFs and their liquidity in your investment decision.

For more information about Harvest ETFs visit harvestportfolios.com

The views and/or opinions expressed above are of a general nature and are for informational purposes only. The contents should not be considered as advice and/or a recommendation to purchase or sell the mentioned securities or used to engage personal investment strategies. Investors should consult their investment advisor before making any investment decision.

Commissions, management fees and expenses all may be associated with investing in Harvest Exchange Traded Funds (managed by Harvest Portfolios Group Inc. (the “Funds”). The funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. Please read the relevant prospectus before investing.